Portrait of Dr. Benjamin Rush by Charles Willson Peale (1741-1827). Wikimedia Commons.
Two hundred years ago, American physician Benjamin Rush published his extensive guide to the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness, Medical Inquiries and Observations Upon Diseases of the Mind. Before Rush’s time, there was little knowledge on how to care for mentally ill patients. In fact, when Rush joined the staff at Philadelphia’s Pennsylvania Hospital in 1783, there were two dozen “lunatics” (to use the parlance of the day) kept in unheated basement cells. Rush argued for their comfort and worked to improve their living conditions. But many of his recommended therapies would seem strange, and even inhumane, to the 21st century reader.
In an article I wrote for The Pennsylvania Gazette, I interviewed contemporary therapists about Rush’s complex legacy to the mental-health field:
“It really is a mix of things,” says Robert DeRubeis, chair of the psychology department at the University of Pennsylvania. Diseases of the Mind includes treatments that therapists “would never do today” because they’re inhumane, ineffective, or theoretically unsound. “They range from alarming to eyebrow-raising to bemusing when you read about them,” DeRubeis says. “But then there are another set of treatments he describes that are perfectly sensible—some of which are in quite widespread use today and some of which should be in more widespread use.”
In Benjamin Rush: Patriot and Physician, biographer Alyn Brodsky writes that, as flawed as it was, Diseases of the Mind “was so complete and so unique a study of mental diseases that it remained the only comprehensive American study on the subject for seventy years, and was the foundation upon which superseding studies incorporating scientific advances were based.” Brodsky adds, “We can attribute to Rush’s efforts more innovation in the hospitalizing and treatment—above all, the understanding—of the mentally afflicted than to any other physician of his time.”
Below are just a few of Rush’s remedies for various afflictions. (Keep in mind the diagnosis terms are not ones in use today.) To find out what contemporary therapists at the University of Pennsylvania have to say about these and other therapies, see my sidebar in the Gazette.
For general intellectual derangement
Pennsylvania Hospital, William Strickland. Image in public domain due to age.
by means of a strait waistcoat, or of a chair, which I have called a tranquilizer. He submits to them both with less difficulty than to human force, and struggles less to disengage himself from them. The tranquilizer has several advantages over the strait waistcoat or mad shirt. It opposes the impetus of the blood towards the brain, it lessens muscular action every where, it reduces the force and frequency of the pulse, it favours the application of cold water and ice to the head, and warm water to the feet, both of which, I shall say presently, are excellent remedies in this disease; it enables physician to feel the pulse and to bleed without any trouble, or altering the erect position of the patient’s body; and, lastly, it relieves him, by means of a close stool, half filled with water, over which he constantly sits, from the foeter and filth of his alvine evacuations.
It should be copious on the first attack of the disease. From 20 to 40 ounces of blood may be taken at once, unless fainting be induced before that quantity be drawn. It will do most service if the patient be bled in a standing position. The effects of this early and copious bleeding are wonderful in calming mad people. It often prevents the necessity of using any other remedy, and sometimes it cures in a few hours.
Low diet, consisting wholly of vegetables, and those of the least nutritious nature
By Garelvirat. Flickr Creative Commons.
Cold, in the form of air, water and ice.
The hair should be cut off, and shaved from every part of the head … by cutting off, we not only expose the head to a greater degree of cold, but we favour by it, at the same time, depletion from the brain, by means of insensible perspiration.
Cold water should be applied … to the head … by means of cloths, or a bladder, to which ice, when it can be obtained, should be added … The coldnesss should be frequently renewed, and they should be continued for several days and nights. The signal for removing them should be, when they produce chilliness, and sobbing or weeping in the patient.
In order to derive benefit from the application of cold water to the whole body, it should be immersed in it for several hours, by which means we prevent the re-action of the system and thus render the sedative effects of the water permanent.
Destruction of the old association of ideas.
Every thing a hypochondriac patient sees or hears, becomes tinctured with some sad idea of his disease … Change therefore his dress, his room, his habitation, and his company, as often as possible.
Employment, or business of some kind.
Man was made to be active. Even in paradise he was employed in the healthy and pleasant exercises of cultivating a garden. Happiness, consisting in folded arms and in pensive contemplations, beneath rural shades, and by the side of purling brooks, never had any existence, except in the brains of mad poets, and love-sick girls and boys.
Cultivating a garden, 18th-century English woodcut.
These should be preferred, which, while they interest the mind, afford exercise to the body. The chase, shooting, playing as quoits, are all useful for this purpose. … Chess, checkers, cards, and even push-pin should be preferred to idleness, when the weather forbids exercise in the open air. The theatre has often been resorted to, to remove fits of low spirits;: and it is a singular fact, that a tragedy oftener dissipates them than a comedy… Certain animals suspend the anguish of the mind of this disease by their innocence, ingenuity, or sports.
Music has often afforded great relief in this disease. .. I attended a citizen of Philadelphia, occasionally in the paroxysm of this disease who informed me that he was cured of one of them by hearing the old hundred psalm tune sung in a country church ….
This should consist of swinging, seesaw, and an exercise discovered by Dr. Cox, which promises more than either of them, and this is, subjecting the patient to a rotary motion, so as to give a centrifugal direction of the blood towards the brain … I have contrived a machine for this purpose in our hospital, which produces the same effects upon the body … These are vertigo and nausea, and a general perspiration. I have called it Gyrator. … It produces great changes in the pulse. In one experiment made with it, it increased the pulse from 84 to 88 strokes in one minutes, and to 120 in two minutes.
has several advantages over exercise, in being not only more stimulating, but more durable in its effects, whereby it is more calculated to arrest wrong habits of action, and to restore such as are regular and natural. It has been remarked that the maniacs of the male sex in all hospitals, who assist in cutting wood, making fires, and digging in a garden, and the females who are employed in washing, ironing, and scrubbing floors, often recover, while persons, whose rank exempts them from performing such services, languish away their lives within the walls of the hospital.
For derangement of the passions (grief)
It should be given in liberal doses in its first paroxysm, and it should be repeated afterwards, in order to obviate wakefulness.
1743 gravestone – Church of St. Peter-in-the-Great Valley, Saint Peter’s Road (East Whiteland Township), Devault, Chester County, PA. Library of Congress.
Persons afflicted with grief should be advised to receive the visits of their friends, of whom the physician should always be one … They should imitate the conduct of Job’s friends, who after weeping for his losses and afflictions when they beheld him afar off … “sat down with him upon the ground, seven days and seven nights, and none spake a word to him, for they saw his grief was very great.” … There is science, as well as sympathy in this silence, for in this way, grief most rapidly passes from the bosom of the sufferer into that of his friend.
The persons afflicted with grief should be carried from the room in which their relations have died, nor should they ever see their bodies afterwards. They should by no means be permitted to follow them to the grave. It would be useful to inter the body of the deceased as far as possible from the view of the person, who is the subject of grief … After the expiration of the weeks of mourning, care should be taken never to mention the names of the deceased persons to any of their friends, nor to allude to any thing that by means of association can revive their memory.